“સંભારણાં”ના વાચકોના પ્રતિભાવ

૧) મારા પ્રથમ પુસ્તક “સંભારણાં”નો રીવ્યુ ટાઈમ્સ ઓફ ઇન્ડિયા ગ્રુપ’ના પ્રતિષ્ઠિત ગુજરાતી અખબાર નવગુજરાત સમય’ની તારીખ ૦૬.૦૫.૨૦૧૫ની આવૃત્તિમાં કદર અને કિતાબ’ કોલમમાં જાણીતા પ્રોફેસર શ્રી સંજય ભાવે દ્વારા થયો છે, જે આપ સર્વેની જાણ માટે અહીં રજૂ કરું છું:

20150528_200612

૨) શ્રી રસિકભાઈ એમ. વેદિયા, અમદાવાદ

20150528_195547

20150528_195614

૩) શ્રી હસમુખભાઈ ત્રિવેદી, અમદાવાદ

20150528_200116

20150528_200148

ઇમેલથી મળેલ પ્રતિભાવ:

શ્રી પ્રતાપભાઈ પારેખ, મુંબઈ

Dear Sureshbhai Trivedi,

My friend Mr. Bharatbhai Trivedi  had handed me a book titled as “સંભારણાં” few days back. Honestly, I kept it in my desk without having much look at it & not bothered to go through it. But last week  when I opened it & started reading it I found it very interesting narration. It reminded my own childhood as I was also born in the year 1954 & spent my childhood in small town Jamnagar.

Honestly speaking, I liked your book very much. Its your nice & precise observation of a village life of our country & particularly of Gujarat rural life of past period of 1960-1980. You have not only covered the “Pros or cons” of  the village life what you have experienced during your childhood & young age in small village named “માડકા” (Banaskantha Dist.). but you have also remarked on social evils prevailing in our society at that time. Your views on our village life’s shortcomings/social evils & write ups & suggestions on improvement of village social life are really true & praiseworthy.

My sincere compliments to you for publishing such wonderful creation. I am also thankful to my friend Bharatbhai Trivedi who has given me this book “સંભારણાં”.

With warm Regards

Pratap Parekh

18 /B, Setu Bldg., 11, Dattatray Road ,

Santacruz-West, Mumbai-400054

Mobile : +919833436321

શ્રી પ્રવિણસિંહ જાડેજા, અમદાવાદ

On Sat, Mar 7, 2015 at 11:02 AM, PS jadeja. <jadejaps@rediffmail.com> wrote:

Dear Shri Trivedisaheb,
 
Thanks for presenting me ” Sambharana”  your first presentation as writer to me, which I found very sweet  & interesting. It is true remembrance of your childhood life in a village… compliments for wonderful narration, which describes only and only truth on day to day life of the than India, with depth and good suggestions too.
 
It resembles to my experience of staying in villages, where in I stayed during my childhood. My father being a doctor in primary health centre had worked in many villages in Kheda & vadodara Districts during sixty and seventies.
 
With your considerable readings on various subjects, I suggest you to continue your  writing on various subjects, one of them could be experience of banking we show and handled when we joined the bank and in particular tackling various situations in day to day banking at various point of time. We started working in bank with most of the things done manually  with no computers or even calculators. Experiences of balancing books, tire some closings, calculation of interest and it’s applications all this may be very interesting for the newcomers in the bank.
 
Once again thanks for providing such an opportunity to go back in the past with wonderful & true narration.
 
Regards,
 
Yours,
Pravinsinh Jadeja.
શ્રી કિરણસિંહ રાજપૂત, માડકા

Namaskar  Sir.

Your publication “Sambharna” is very good. I and my father have read it and he told me to send message to you. He likes your thoughts  and what you have written.

Thanks sir for writing such memories .

Yours faithfully
Kiransinh Okhaji Rajput,
Son of Okhaji Rudaji Rajput, Madka

વોટ્સ એપ પર મળેલ પ્રતિભાવ:

16:57, 20 Jun – Anand C Trivedi

‘સંભારણા’ – આપનું સુંદર પુસ્તક વાંચવાની શરૂઆત કરી અને પ્રવાહી લેખનશૈલી અને સરળ વર્ણનને કારણે એકજ બેઠકે વંચાઇ ગયું. સરસ વાક્ય રચનાને લીધે તમારી સાથે-સાથે અમે પણ પુસ્તકમાં વર્ણવેલાં એ સ્થળોની પ્રત્યક્ષ મુલાકાત લીધી હોય એવી અનુભૂતિ થઇ.

બીજા પ્રકરણમાં ચીમનબાપુના વ્યક્તિત્વ વિશેનું લખાણ વાંચતી વખતે જુની યાદો તાજી થઈ. નાનપણમાં વાવ જવાનું થતું ત્યારે તેમને મળ્યાનું પણ યાદ આવ્યું. એમને જોઈને રતિલાલ બાપુને મેં કહેલું, “આ દાદા તો ‘સરદાર’ પટેલ જેવા લાગે છે.” અને એમણે પ્રેમાળ સ્મિત આપી મમ્મી ને કહ્યું. ‘ શુશી, તારો આ છોકરો છે હોશિયાર!’

તમારા પ્રિય લેખકો (જે મને પણ પ્રિય છે) એવા ર.વ. દેસાઈ અને ક.મા.મુન્સીના તમે વાંચેલા પુસ્તકોની સંખ્યા ઉપરથી જ તમારો સાહિત્ય પ્રત્યેનો વિશેષ લગાવ જણાઇ આવે છે. અને પુસ્તક આટલું રસાળ બની શક્યું છે એ કદાચ એની પણ અસર જ સ્તો. પુસ્તકમાં જૂની વાતો, જૂના પ્રશ્નોની સાથે ‘કરંટ અફેર્સ’ ને પણ સારી રીતે સમાવી લેવા એ આપની આગવી વિશેષતા છે.

ખરેખર આપનું આ પુસ્તક મૌલિક, રસપ્રદ, જ્ઞાનવર્ધક, વ્યવહારિક, માહિતીપ્રદ તેમજ પ્રેરણાલક્ષી તો છે જ, તદુપરાંત સાચા અને સારા મૂલ્યોને સમજાવે પણ છે.

‘સંભારણા’ વાંચતા-વાંચતા જૂના સંસ્મરણો પણ તાજા થયા. મજા આવી. ભવિષ્યમાં આવનારા નવા પુસ્તકની રાહ માં…..

આનંદ ત્રિવેદી, અમદાવાદ, 15.06.2015

ફેસબુક પર મળેલ પ્રતિભાવ:

Prabodh Jha 

Going through the book I felt my days since childhood to becoming an adult in an Ahmedabad Pole, opening page by page before my eyes vividly, at some moments while reading, it put me down memory lane and I became emotional. But it was all due to your great writing skill and the style of narrative that made it possible to be really engrossed in the book. Congratulations for this. And I too have started writing, though in initial stages, but I have started feeling what it takes to put one’s thoughts in black and white in such an organised way as you have done. All the appreciation for this. Hope realising your such latent talent vide this book, may you inspire for coming out with write ups regularly.

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 18 June at 11:30

Saahir Ludhinavi has rightly said in one of his couplets ‘duniyane tajurbaat-o hawadis (experince and accidents) ki saql me jo kuch diya hai lauta raha hun’. We all must strive in whatever capacity to commit to rededicate ourselves to the society to which we owe our existence and yours is a beginning with in this sense and thanks for the book

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 18 June at 11:36

Vikram Shahani

Nice pic….but your inner picture which reflects through your book is much much more beautiful….! I have gone through all your articles published in the book and enjoyed it a lot….your writing is as matured as of any Gujarati writers. It may be due to your vast reading & awareness of your surroundings. You have got a very matured writer within you.… I request you to keep on writing sir… ! Good luck…

unlike · reply · 1 · 16 june at 21:54

Ramesh Soni :  Congrats sir….

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 6 May at 22:26

Sonal Trivedi :  I m proud of u papa. Congratulations papa.

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 7 May at 11:24

Himanshu Patel :   Very nice sir, village na chitra ne shabdo ma lakhva badal abhinandan, chepter ma village nu drashya najar same avi jay chhe

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 12 May at 21:09

Kamini Vora :  Abhinandan sir -gaurav anubhavie chhie

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 14 May at 11:04

Jaydev Trivedi :  New Suresh after retirement! Carry On !

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 6 May at 13:38

Umesh Trivedi  :  Congratulations!

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 6 May at 13:43

Neela Dave :  Congrats

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 6 May at 13:51

Kapilaben Trivedi :  Congrats your talent got recognized.

Unlike · Reply · 2 · 6 May at 14:13

Ramanbhai K. Patel :  Sir, Very much Thanks for such a very informative Blog. May GOD bless you for All the Best for All & Forever in Life.

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 19 May at 08:37

Prabhudan Gadhavi :  Abhinandan Sureshbhai

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 30 May at 17:19

Jayant Danak :  Good command on language an impressive presentation through simple words.

Unlike · Reply · 1 · 30 May at 22:09

Advertisements

One comment

મારો અભિપ્રાય

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / બદલો )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / બદલો )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / બદલો )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / બદલો )

Connecting to %s